At last month’s gathering of the International Association of Scientologists (IAS) in East Grinstead, Sussex, reclusive Scientology leader David Miscavige claimed victory, announcing that a decades-long surveillance program of their organisation by the German Government had finally come to an end. However, after reaching out to Germany’s domestic intelligence service, the Bundesamt für Verfassungsschutz (BfV, or Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution) we can confirm that although Scientology is no longer listed as a specific, individual threat, Miscavige’s claims were in fact, false.
In Germany, the Church of Scientology is considered a threat to democracy and has been closely monitored by the BfV since at least 1997. Since then, numerous attempts have been made by the Church to challenge its status in the country. In 2004 a federal court ruled L. Ron Hubbard’s writings were incompatible with the German constitution. At the time, lawyers representing the BfV argued that Scientology were taking systematic steps to infiltrate society and government, attempting to prevent “anti-Scientology legislation” and that the organisation teaches civil rights should be restricted only to Scientologists. The Church rejected these claims, but the judge disagreed and ruled that the aims of Scientology do, in fact, include the abrogation of human rights and equality.
When Scientology opened a new ‘Ideal Org’ in Berlin in 2007, German federal and state interior ministers again voiced their concerns about the organisation. In a report published at the time, the IMK (Standing Conference of Interior Ministers and Senators) warned that Scientology’s activities are “designed to create dependency” and emphasised “the need for intensified preventive efforts, particularly in addressing the organisation’s criminal methods.” It concluded “the Scientology organisation continues to pursue objectives that are hostile to the constitutional order” and recommended continued intelligence gathering as a result.
In 2013, the US Department of State’s report into religious freedom in Germany explained the complex relationship between Scientology and the authorities:
“The status of the Church of Scientology remains in limbo. The Constitutional Court and various courts at the state level have not explicitly ruled that Scientology is a religion. Government agencies at the federal and state level have rules and procedures that discriminate against Scientology as a group and against its members. Four of the major political parties (the Christian Democratic Union, Christian Social Union, Social Democratic Party, and Free Democratic Party) ban Scientologists from party membership. […] Scientologists reported instances of governmental discrimination.
Although courts at the state and federal level condemned the improper use of so-called ‘sect filters’ to blacklist and boycott Scientologists, they remained in use in the public sector. ‘Sect filters’ typically asked potential new employees to confirm in writing that they had no contact with Scientology, did not participate in its training courses, and rejected its doctrines. […] Catholic and Protestant churches continued to oppose Scientology publically [sic], although press reporting and public reactions to Scientology decreased. Several private organizations issued warnings about after-school study programs run by Scientologists.”
U.S. Department of State – Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labor (2014), Germany. International Religious Freedom Report for 2012
Since then, the release of damning documentaries such as Alex Gibney’s ‘Going Clear‘ and A&E’s ‘Leah Remini: Scientology and the Aftermath‘, as well as a rise in former members turning to platforms like YouTube to speak out against the so-called Church, has led Scientology to struggle in its bid to recruit new members and stay relevant. Many of it’s ‘Orgs’ around the world are reportedly empty the majority of the time, and eyewitness accounts from their large international gatherings suggest attendance has fallen dramatically over the years.
In a post published on his blog in 2021, former Scientology spokesman Mike Rinder explained “Germany is not fooled by scientology. They see through the front groups and campaigns as charades to recruit new members.”
Although Scientology does not publish its membership figures, the German authorities estimated in 2021 there were only around 3,500 Scientologists in the country, the BfV telling us in an exclusive statement the organisation has now “lost relevance” at the federal level. And so, earlier this year the German Government felt it was no longer possible to justify naming Scientology on its list of organisations it considers to be a threat to their constitution. Miscavige, of course, took this to mean they were off the hook and proudly announced at last month’s IAS event that he had pioneered a victory against “a relentless campaign of government-sponsored religious persecution in the heart of a modern Western democracy.”
So we reached out to the BfV to ask if their surveillance program had indeed come to an end. Here is what they told us:
“When monitoring activities directed against the liberal democratic basic order pursuant to Section 3(1) of the Federal Constitutional Protection Act (BVerfSchG), the BfV classifies findings into so-called “phenomenon areas” such as right-wing extremism, left-wing extremism, or Islamism. This ideological classification of extremist activities serves organizational purposes.
Since the “Scientology Organization” has lost relevance at the federal level in recent years, the BfV no longer treats it as a separate, nationwide phenomenon area. Consequently, it is no longer listed separately in the VSB.
Regardless of this, however, activities directed against the liberal democratic basic order that originate from the “Scientology Organization” will continue to be addressed by the BfV.“
Statement from the German Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, November 2026
In other words, the German Government now considers Scientology to be irrelevant due to its shrinking size and influence and as such, it is no longer included as a named entity on its list of dangerous groups worthy of independent monitoring. The Church on the other hand argues the German Government is guilty of “brainwashing” its people against them and that “after 29 years of allegations, investigations and relentless government scrutiny, Germany’s federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution finally threw in the towel” and ended it’s surveillance program.
But despite Miscavige’s claims, German intelligence services are continuing to monitor Scientology’s activities and the BfV have not changed their view that Hubbard’s teachings pose a threat to human rights and democracy.
Journalist Tony Ortega, who has been writing about Scientology for more than 30 years at The Underground Bunker, told us “Scientology was never as large as it pretended to be. It has claimed to have tens of millions of members since the 1960s, but its high water mark was probably around the year 1990, and with about 100,000 members worldwide, not millions. But even at that more modest size, it posed a serious threat that the German government recognized and devoted resources to keep tabs on. Under L. Ron Hubbard’s successor David Miscavige, however, Scientology has hemorrhaged members and influence. The German government still considers it a threat, as this letter shows, but it cannot devote the same resources to such a deflated movement. Miscavige has no choice but to turn this into a victory for Scientology. It’s what his job has become full time: turning the obvious signs of Scientology’s decline into propaganda to placate his remaining wealthy donors.”




Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.